SQL SERVER – Create a Comma Delimited List Using SELECT Clause From Table Column

I received following question in email : How to create a comma delimited list using SELECT clause from table column?

Answer is to run following script.

USE AdventureWorks
SELECT @listStr = COALESCE(@listStr+',' ,'') + Name
FROM Production.Product
SELECT @listStr

SQL SERVER - Create a Comma Delimited List Using SELECT Clause From Table Column notes85-800x536

I have previously written a similar article where I have demonstrated this method using three sample examples. You can read the article for further information. SQL SERVER – Creating Comma Separate Values List from Table – UDF – SP

Here are few of the interesting articles related to this blog post:

Simple CSV implementations may prohibit field values that contain a comma or other special characters such as CSV. The CSV file format is not standardized. CSV is a common data exchange format that is widely supported by consumer, business, and scientific applications. CSV formats are best used to represent sets or sequences of records in which each record has an identical list of fields.

Reference : Pinal Dave (https://blog.sqlauthority.com)

CSV, Database, SQL Function, SQL Scripts, SQL Server, SQL Stored Procedure
Previous Post
SQL SERVER – Example of DISTINCT in Aggregate Functions
Next Post
SQL SERVER – Compound Assignment Operators – A Simple Example

Related Posts

109 Comments. Leave new

  • Hi Pinal,

    there is a task in which user is asking for comma delimited text file. i am running the query in sql server 2008.

  • Hello Pinal,
    I have a problem I have been trying to solve. I have an EDI 834 text file I need to parse into a SQL table using multiple custom delimiters. The file is delimited with a { and member data between different leading identifiers, for example ~DTP{348{D8{20121101~AMT{C1{0 would mean for the month of 2012 10 01 the copay would be $0. The other leading indentifiers would be ~INS – Insured Benefit OR MEMBER LEVEL DETAIL
    ~REF – Reference Information : The REF segment is required to link the dependent(s) to the subscriber.PRIOR COVERAGE MONTHS
    ~DTP – Date or Time or Period
    ~NM1 – Individual or Organizational Name : Either NM1 or N1 will be included depending on whether an individual or organization is being specified. MEMBER EMPLOYER or RESPONSIBLE PERSON
    ~PER – Administrative Communications Contact
    ~N3 – Party Location
    ~N4 – Geographic Location
    ~DMG – Demographic Information
    ~LS – Loop Header
    EC – Employment Class
    ~LS – Loop Header
    ~LX – Transaction Set Line Number
    ~N1 – Party Identification
    ~REF – Reference Information
    ~AMT – Monetary Amount Information
    ~LX – Transaction Set Line Number
    ~N1 – Party Identification
    ~DTP – Date or Time or Period
    ~LE – Loop Trailer
    ~SE – Transaction Set Trailer
    Any help of direction would great.

    SELECT @listStr = COALESCE(@listStr+’,’ ,”) + COALESCE(Name,”)
    FROM Production.Product
    SELECT @listStr

    COALESCE would be required for “Name” too

    • Where is the order no this is just the list of products ,i need orderno & corresponding products seperated by comma

  • David P. Austin
    April 23, 2013 8:08 pm

    How could you create a set of inline comma-separated values for a query? For example, I tried to show orders and include the orderTypes from a cross-reference table:

    SELECT OrderId, Name,
    SELECT COALESCE(Name+’, ‘ ,”) + Name
    FROM OrderType JOIN OrderType_XR ON OrderType_XR.OrderTypeId = OrderType.OrderTypeId WHERE OrderType_XR.OrderId=OrderId
    FROM Order

    but SQL Server reports “Subquery returned more than 1 value. This is not permitted when the subquery follows =, !=, <, , >= or when the subquery is used as an expression.” Can this be done inline or would I need a SQL function?

    • satish kumar
      May 18, 2013 2:38 pm

      Declare @Orders
      SELECT @Orders = COALESCE(@Orders + ‘,’ ,’ ‘ ) + OrderCOL_Name FROM
      SELECT Order FROM OrderTable
      )AS MyCommaOrderedList;

  • what is alternative to comma separated list in Sql.i have a query suppose i need to store data of some customer as cust_name,cust_id,add,phno,date,items(one by one in separate column or in list ) and price of each item and quantity then the total. how can i design my db as columns here vary dynamically

  • Praveen Nihalani
    July 26, 2013 5:06 pm

    can anybody help me to find the equivalent function WM_CONCAT(Oracle) in sql server

  • Suraj Deshpande
    August 7, 2013 5:19 pm

    Fantastic article. !!

  • krunal kakadiya
    August 21, 2013 3:49 pm

    hi all,

    i am passing comma separated values to my stored procedure. something like below:


    now if want something like below:

    id firstname
    1 a
    2 b
    3 c
    4 d

    how can we do this?

  • Hi Dears,
    i need this query with where condition
    like below
    USE AdventureWorks
    DECLARE @listStr VARCHAR(MAX),@parameter varchar(10),@table_name varchar(10)
    set @parameter=’Tag_no=1′
    set @table_name=’name’
    SELECT @listStr = COALESCE(@listStr+’,’ ,”) + @table_name
    FROM online where where + @parameter

    above query show like this
    USE AdventureWorks
    DECLARE @listStr VARCHAR(MAX),@parameter varchar(10),@table_name varchar(10)
    set @parameter=’Tag_no=1′
    set @table_name=’name’
    SELECT @listStr = COALESCE(@listStr+’,’ ,”) name
    FROM online where where Tag_no
    this query not executing pls any one help me

  • Your examples are always the most helpful and easy to follow. Thanks for your help, this is exactly what I needed!

  • Hi pinal, the above given example wont handle null as u commented . For eexample

    create table people
    ( name nvarchar(10)

    insert INTO people VALUES (‘a’),(‘b’),(‘c’),(NULL),(‘d’),(‘e’)
    SELECT * FROM people

    DECLARE @Names VARCHAR(8000)
    SELECT @Names = isnull(@Names+’,’,”)+name FROM people
    SELECT @Names

    The above will result in d,e
    not as expected from a,b,c,d,e

  • none of this stuff is usefull, if you wanted all rows you can exctract it and do it in xl.
    How do you do it IN sql, where each group is concatenated into a string.

  • DECLARE @List VARCHAR(8000)

    SELECT @List = COALESCE(@List + ‘,’, ”) + CAST(LinkedLocationId AS VARCHAR)
    FROM UserMaster
    WHERE LinkedLocationId = 1

    SELECT @List

    — It Gives following error
    Msg 245, Level 16, State 1, Line 3
    Conversion failed when converting the varchar value ‘27,69,70,1,73’ to data type int.


  • I’m trying to make this work in SQL2000 and it won’t work. The column list seems to be dieing at the first “null” valued column

    My procedure is:

    — =============================================
    CREATE procedure [dbo].[CloneRow]

    @tableName varchar(255),

    @keyName varchar(255),

    @oldKeyId int,

    @newTableId int output


    declare @sqlCommand nvarchar(255),

    @columnList varchar(255);

    select @columnList = COALESCE(@columnList+’,’ ,”) + Name

    from syscolumns

    where object_name(syscolumns.id) = @tableName

    and syscolumns.name not in ( @keyName )

    and iscomputed = 0;

    set @sqlCommand = ‘insert into ‘ + @tableName + ‘ ( ‘ + @columnList + ‘) (‘ +

    ‘select ‘ + @columnList + ‘ from ‘ + @tableName + ‘ where ‘ + @keyName + ‘ = @oldKeyId )’

    exec sp_executesql @sqlCommand, N’@oldKeyId int’, @oldKeyId = @oldKeyId

    select @newTableId = @@identity — note scope_identity() won’t work here!

  • Loving your Plural Sight courses, you the man!, now to wrap each list item with single quotes..

    USE AdventureWorks
    SELECT @listStr = COALESCE(@listStr+’,’ ,”)+ CHAR(39) + Name+CHAR(39)
    FROM Production.Product
    SELECT @listStr

  • gaurav jha
    May 2, 2014 3:24 pm

    How does this really works…

  • muchas gracias,
    thanks you very much.

  • I know this is an old post, but I find it strange that you would recommend this as a solution when it is taking advantage of what some may call a “bug.” There are several other ways to do this using recursive CTEs or FOR XML PATH. In my opinion, this should produce a runtime error stating something like “More than one value returned from results set”, as is what happens when you say WHERE someColumn = (SELECT someOtherColumn FROM someTable) and the subquery returns more than 1 value. What are your thoughts on MS changing this behavior, or is it documented that this is intended behavior?

  • Hi Pinal, I am looking for solution which can be compatible in Azure SQL Dataware house.

    It will be help full if you can share same answer for Azure SQL DW.

  • IF OBJECT_ID(‘tempdb..#tmp_Example’) is not null
    DROP TABLE #tmp_Example

    create table #tmp_Example
    ApplicationID int,
    Comments varchar(8000)

    insert into #tmp_Example
    (ApplicationID, Comments)
    (123, ‘This is comment 1, Comment 2, Comment 3, Comment 4, Comment 5’),
    (321, ‘Comment 1’),
    (542, ‘Comment 1, Comment 2, Comment 3, Comment 4, Comment 5, Comment 6, Comment 7, Comment 8’)

    SELECT row_number() OVER (
    PARTITION BY a.ApplicationID ORDER BY a.ApplicationID
    ) AS ID,
    y.i.value(‘(./text())[1]’, ‘nvarchar(4000)’) as Comments
    FROM (
    SELECT t1.ApplicationID,
    x = CONVERT(XML, ‘‘ + REPLACE(t1.Comments, ‘,’, ‘‘) + ‘‘).query(‘.’)
    FROM #tmp_Example t1
    ) AS a
    CROSS APPLY x.nodes(‘i’) AS y(i)


Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Exit mobile version